The Guest Blog

Guest blogpost by Coen van de Ven, originally published on Europe’s Footsteps.

In North Africa, the dust of the Arab Spring has settled and new regimes have been established. But while Tunisia is praised as ‘country of the year’ by The Economist, Libya has fallen into dissension and Egypt is back at the point it was before the revolution. Unfortunately for Libya and Egypt: the EU seems more eager to help democracies rather than chaotic states.

Those who walk through the streets of Tunis, Tunisia, nowadays, will notice the leaps forward the country has made since the Arab spring. Bookstores are stuffed with books which were forbidden under former president Ben Ali and the newspapers are filled with new and uncensored content. Freedom of speech – which is immured in the country’s brand new constitution – has obviously changed a lot.

If we take a look at Tunisia’s neighbours Egypt and Libya, we see the other side of the ‘Arabic Spring’. General Sisi is ruling in a similar way as Mubarak and Libya has fallen into disunity, which is expressed through the many factions and the two parliaments the country has at the moment. Add to it a shattered airport and the destroyed infrastructure in general. Why is Tunisia so successful while its neighbours are falling apart?

“The absence of a strong and overruling army as you have in Egypt is a real difference,” says Jan Jaap de Ruiter, assistant professor in Arabic culture and publicist. “Also the lack of different groups as in Libya and the fact that Tunisia is not a strategic piece of North-Africa helped.”

Egypt, which can be seen as a strategic piece of land due to its border with Israel, had simply a too strong regime under Mubarak, says Emeritus Professor William Zartman, who is a renowned publicist and founder of the International Peace and Security Institute. “The Liberal forces and popular protesters were so strongly influenced by Mubarak’s Mukhabarat [Intelligent service] that they had no organisation, no strategy and no unity. Three things in which the military excelled.” De Ruiter adds: “General Sisi can be considered a Mubarak II.”

Tunisia is a totally different story. There is no such progressive constitution in the Arabic world such as the one Tunisia approved last year. The new document, which took two years to draft, due to a vigorous debate and two assassinations, secures human rights and more popular sovereignty. “With the birth of this text, we confirm our victory over dictatorship,” said interim-president of Tunisia and human rights activist Moncef Marzouki after the new document was launched. And yes: the traces of the human rights activists are clearly visible in the document: for example men and women are equal and the constitution doesn’t mention Islam or other religions at all. “Much work remains, to make the values of our constitution a part of our culture,” Marzouki said.

It’s obvious that the country could use some extra help here from the west, but how? During the outbreak of the Arab Spring, international powers were slow in their reaction. The EU wasn’t able to formulate a clear and direct answer to the events and The United States were ambivalent about dropping Mubarak as an ally. They only dropped him when it became clear that him leaving was inevitable; the former-Egyptian leader took a key-role in strategic USA–Middle East relations.

America’s strategic interests in North Africa are limited to Egypt; other states in this region are secondary, Volker Perthes, director of Director of the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP), writes. “Washington made that very clear in connection with the Libyan war, which it would have preferred to leave completely to its European allies.”

This of course gave space to big neighbour Europe. “The European Union has to be a union and not 28 different states,” Professor Zartman says. Jan Jaap de Ruiter doesn’t see the need for this: “It’s too early to expect that the 28 member states will formulate a joint vision, but this is not a problem at all. As long as the EU is struggling with the democratic deficit, different nations will want to decide for themselves when it comes to situations likes this.”

France for example was really quick to respond to Libya’s uprising, Britain followed shortly afterwards and Germany wasn’t in the spotlight at all. But maybe more invisible than Germany was Catherine Ashton, High Representative of the European Union and in theory the face of the EU across the continent’s borders.

Numbers prove the individual approach of the different member states. Tunisia for example receives 52 percent of its total support (423 million Euros) from France while Germany is more eager to sponsor Egypt. Libya in its turn mainly depends on the generosity of the United States.

Muriel Asseburg, researcher at SWP, concludes that the EU only booked success in countries where the democratic process has already started: “Tunisia is definitely the one example where the EU was able to support the institutional process, competitive elections, and civil society, and thus contribute to a political transition toward a more participatory, inclusive, and pluralist political system.” He is more critical about the EU’s approach when it comes to nations that underwent a ‘rougher’ Arab Spring. “The EU and its member states have been largely reduced to being bystanders,” he writes. Failed interventions in Afghanistan and Iraq have scared the EU and western countries in general which has resulted in waiting with military action until it is really inevitable.

Total amount of aid coming from EU-institutions. (© OECD/DAC)

The EU wasn’t completely absent. On the contrary, it did really quickly launch a 350 million Euro programme called SPRING (Support to Partnership, Reform and Inclusive Growth), in order to support North Africa financially in democratic reforms. This only works out for stable regimes as seen in Tunisia. Recent aid-numbers by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) from EU-institutions towards North-Africa between 2011 and 2013 shows this very well: Tunisia received 1.4bn Euros, Egypt €835m Euros and Libya only €139m

If you take into consideration that Libya has the most disruptive problems and Egypt is much larger than Tunisia, you have a remarkable spread of aid. The EU has proven its preference for young democracies above turbulent states, with a 2013 decision to cut Egypt’s aid completely.

The wound of intervening in Afghanistan and Iraq is still fresh. And with a union divided when it come to foreign affairs, it seems safe to bet on young democracies which will reward with satisfying results in the end.

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0
Author :
Print

Comments

  1. Pingback: Homepage
  2. Pingback: luchtfoto
  3. Hello
    We admire you for taking the first step in putting up your own business. We want to assist you in bringing your dream into fruition by providing you the low-interest business loan and other credit facilities that you need to expand or pay for the start-up expenses.

    Though there are many financing companies out there that refuse to provide start-up loans and other credit facilities with the belief that they are too risky. Our company is not one of them. We understand the importance of getting a business jumpstarted and are not afraid to be of assistance.

    We offer business loans, housing loans, bank guarantee, standby Letter of Credit; Letter of credits, Medium term notes, and so many others from AAA rated banks between US$100,000 – US$1 Billion at 3% minimal interest and leasing rates. We cover all your credit facilities needs and offer low interest rates and effortless payment plans.
    Other packages include long term project partnership funding, joint ventures partnership, investment funding, invention partnership funding, contract funding and other partnership funding for those that have good business plans and ongoing projects without enough money to finance or complete it.

    Our goal is to be able to help everyone as much as possible, regardless of what your credit report has to say. We didn’t establish our company to discriminate. Email us today and discuss with us to see the great deals we have to offer. We want your business to succeed just as much as you do. Let us assist you
    During our 12 years operation in financing we didn’t receive any negative feedback from our clients.

    If you’re looking for a loan that will fund the establishment or expansion of your own business, we are here to give it to you.
    Email: creditfacilitiesconsultant@gmail.com us today regarding questions you may have and discuss with us to see the great deals we have to offer. We want your business to succeed just as much as you do. Let us assist you. We look forward to serving you.

    I am waiting for your response.

    Best regards
    Michael
    Credit Facilities Consultant

  4. Pingback: buy backlinks
  5. Pingback: cokolwiek
  6. Pingback: budowa
  7. Pingback: user_dashboard
  8. Pingback: tier2
  9. Pingback: tier2 junk
  10. Pingback: kobieta
  11. Pingback: first row
  12. Pingback: Segerstrom Center
  13. Pingback: dig this
  14. Pingback: image source
  15. Pingback: orospu ankara
  16. Pingback: mobile
  17. Pingback: headshots photo
  18. How I Was Rescued By A God Fearing Lender (Lexieloancompany@yahoo.com)

    Hello,

    I am Andrew Thompson by Name currently living in CT USA, God has bless me with two kids and a lovely Wife, I promise to share this Testimony because of God favor in my life, 2days ago I was in desperate need of money so I thought of having a loan then I ran into wrong hands who claimed to be loan lender not knowing he was a scam. he collected 1,500.00 USD from me and refuse to email me since then I was confuse, but God came to my rescue, one faithful day I went to church after the service I share idea with a friend and she introduce me to LEXIE LOAN COMPANY, she said she was given 98,000.00 USD by MR LEXIE , THE MANAGING DIRECTOR OF LEXIE LOAN COMPANY. So I collected his email Address , he told me the rules and regulation and I followed, then after processing of the Documents, he gave me my loan of 55,000.00 USD… So if you are interested in a loan you can as well contact him on this Email: Lexieloancompany@yahoo.com or call +1(406)946-0675 thanks, I am sure he will also help you.

Comments are closed.